Children Who Chase Lost Voices from Deep Below – Review

Post

5 comments   |   Anime Film Reviews


Makoto Shinkai is an interesting fellow. We even had the a chance to interview him a few months back but was told he would be very secretive about this project. You see, Children Who Chase Lost Voices from Deep Below is in fact, his first full featured film. The storyline primarily focuses on the main character Asuna Watase, who is what you could consider a bit of a loner, and way more mature for her age then I probably am now (I’m 26). It is a coming of age story involving young love and a mysterious music, coming from a crystal radio left as a memento by an absent father, that leads a young heroine deep into a hidden world. Heralded as a successor to Hayao Miyazaki for his previous works, such as 5 Centimeters Per Second, Shinkai claims that Children Who Chase Lost Voices From Deep Below is to study on “how people are connected” and the relationship between individuals. I know what everyone is thinking…is it better then 5 Centimeters per Second? Short answer. No. However, this is still better then the majority of anime on the market today.

But as you can expect visual side of this movie is masterpiece. Landscapes made by Shinkai are something like French impressionistic paintings but they are much more detailed, with better colors and lighting. The world of Argatha is not a magical world filled with towering cities powered by magic, but instead more of a rural country with many towns. This in turn leads to my biggest complaint about the film as it is a pity that Shinkai abandons his talent on talking about modern city life but tries to give a tribute to Miyazaki Hayao by duplicating many elements in Ghibli’s anime movies. In the end it just left me confused and I didn’t know how to process the beautiful atmosphere unravaling before me.

Shinkai has always been capable of creating captivating stories about communication and now he can add the mystique of death to his resume. Yes, this film deals with the loss of someone close to you and if you can relate, prepare to shed a tear or two. Children Who Chase Lost Voices From Deep Below is inspired by the Japanese myth of Izanami and Izanagi, an Eastern equivalent of Orpheus and Eurydice, in which Izanagi journeys to Yomi, the underworld, to try and bring his lover back from the dead. If that doesn’t ring a bell, think back to Robin Williams’ What Dreams May Come, which had a similar theme as well. I love the message the movie brought to me. However, the story does have flaws. The pace of some parts is too slow while of some parts is too fast. It can be explained by looking at the length of the movie, which is of the longest in Shinkai’s works.

In the end, I’m not sure if it’s in the animation or the storytelling or what it was, but it felt like I was watching Studio Ghibli more than I was a Makoto Shinkai film. But my expectations are always very high, so there is no doubt they were too high. Still this film comes easily recommended and hopefully will see the light of day in the West. Visually arresting without being flashy, Makoto Shinkai has created a film that is a considerable achievement; a beautiful, horrifying and thrilling film that should delight both anime fans and newbies alike.



Related Posts with Thumbnails

  • Caziro

    Hi
    What do you mean by “his first full-featured movie” ? I can understand that you don’t considerate 5cm/s as one, but what are you doing of Kumo no Mukou, Yakusoku no Basho?

    Also, Miyazaki is surely an influence, but it’s not like Shinkai is throwing away his style. Again, Kumo no Mukou features a lot of rural landscapes (and Children remembered me of some), also, “Astronaut”, the second part of 5cm/s is not really an urban thing. (Not to mention Oukasho (1st part) and the landscapes of Akari’s city.) Shinkai’s cities are amazing, I totally agree, but C not a good idea to limit him at this kind of landscapes. I really don’t think Children’s landscapes are inferior to 5cm/s…

    Shinkai is absolutely not betraying his style and fans, the theme of death involving relationships to end is well done and fits totally with Shinkai’s other wocazirks. (if some characters of 5cm/s knew how to say “goodbye” and cared about peocaziple surrounding them, the movie wouldn’t have end this way)

  • http://japancinema.net Marcello

    I agree that in a sense he isn’t betraying his style, which reminds me of the scene in Kumo no Mukou where Takuya steals the body of the still comatose girl from the military hospital. I suppose what I meant was that this was his longest animation film to date and is described as a “lively” animated film.

    It was very nice for your to respond as you sound like a true Shinkai admirer. Thank you for your feedback.

  • http://www.isugoi.com Miguel

    Good review Marcello. I personally lean more towards this film being more of an “exploratory” phase for Shinkai, and this film felt and looked very Ghibli-esque to me in a lot of ways. I still think it’s a very well done film, but it’s not his best by a substantial margin – and this is coming from someone who really, really enjoys his past work.

    A lot of people have labeled him the next “Miyazaki”, a claim even he flatly denies as rather silly. I personally find the comparison silly as well – Shinkai simply doesn’t have the same volume of work behind him as Miyazaki does – plus his past films have been rather similar thematically. With “Lost Voices” though, it appears that he really tried to explore new and unfamiliar ground, which he isn’t all that successful with – as of yet. His past films have all been rather “small” in terms of story, yet with “Lost Voices” he attempts to make an “epic” film in both tone, setting, and story.

    He’s not quite there yet, but I do commend his effort as both an artist and director for at least trying.

    (P.S.) You can delete my last message, I accidentally double-posted!

  • http://japancinema.net Marcello

    I think you said it best yourself: “One should view the film simply as a preview to Shinkai’s considerable potential as a director more so than being a film that can stand alongside his stunning previous works.” You’re right, he isn’t quite there but I see him becoming a better filmmaker in the years ahead. In the meantime, we get to enjoy his great films leading up to that!

  • billjhcai

    i totally think its a good film, don’t get me wrong, i understand the main topic has been done with different works over a million times, but if you take a closer look at the characters, espacially with the guy who lost his wife and stuff, he is actually very very special, the way i see it.because a normal film would have made him go all crazy and kill people , but in this film, he retained his sense of love and warmth despite the shit he been through, and that’s what i think is really really good